True, you don't have that obligation, nor do you have an obligation to be right, or present a justifiable argument, I just figured it's something you'd want. There are legitimate concerns about your position that you are failing to address, and calling them rabbit holes or answering different questions does nothing to alleviate that. My arguments are not ripped apart by you merely saying that they are. A switch is not broken just because it is in its switched off state. An electrician would laugh at you if you wanted a switch replaced simply because it happens to be in its off state. They may be your response, but they are not direct answers to the question.