Should child molesters be castrated?

By "SM" do you mean Sado-Masochism?

 

Uh, no you are a Homophobe for thinking such a thing...

 

No, I don't agree with cruel and unusual punishment.
If we're going to execute them, there is no reason to mutilate them.

Although I like your solution better, an eunich is still capable of molestation.

 

One more time for clarity (A 42 year old Pro Masculine Minor Attracted NAMBLA member with a 14 year old boy = Pedo or Homo ?

 

Yes, homo-pedo which I believe their are many more of than they would like to admit.

If we throw discretion out the door for sexual deviance, where do we stop?

 

He's a homo. Pedophiles are attracted to children under the age of 10.... the younger they are, the more they like them..... there's another name for those who like kids in puberty/young teens and can't think of it right now.....

Here's an example of how sick pedoes are. About 20+ yrs ago, a friend's niece was raped by her mother's boyfriend when she was only 18 MONTHS OLD..... and the baby girl had an older sister around 5-6 yrs old. He never touched her. Well, that's what the 5 yr old said. Some don't tell b/c they're scared......

He was caught, went to prison for only 6 months and the prison psychiatrist said he was " fit" to live in society again....

Karma has it's way of finding you...... a couple yrs later he died a very violent death on a freeway - car exploded into a fireball during the crash....

 

NAMBLA seeks to lower the age of Consent to 16 Nationally (15 with special considerations) so I don't believe the NAMBLA goal is 11 year olds in most cases. NAMBLA = homo thus the cover & support from ACLU & LGBT crowd .

 

Excuse the late reply. What's wrong with a double punishment?

As for your idea, I would oppose it because whether or not it is intended to be a means of torture is irrelevant...it IS a means of torture...and a civilised nation should never advocate torture as a form of punishment (regardless of the potentially beneficial consequences). I support chemical castration because - as well as being a form of retribution + societal protection - it cures (not in all cases, but in very many) the illness of pedophilia. I believe it IS an illness, and instead of undergoing torture for succumbing to their sick desires, many pedophiles could be cured and could consequently be able to contribute to society. The re-offenders after castration (the ones that do not molest solely for sexual satisfaction) should be given the death sentence.

 

Chemical castration reduces libido to the point where it is practically non-existant...this is more than merely inhibiting the ability to achieve an erection.

Many people have brought up the point about some molesters not being cured through castration because the motivation for their crimes runs deeper than sexual gratification. Once again (should've made this clearer in the OP, but I figured it was common sense), I am suggesting this procedure happens at the end of a prison sentence, NOT as a replacement - "usual prison time + castration" as opposed to just "usual prison time"...so the point about it not working for all individuals is irrelevant.

 

There is nothing de-humanising about attempting to cure a disease.

 

you do realize chemical castration is already in place in 9 states?

The thread title distinctly says "child molesters". If you think running naked at a major sporting event = molesting, you are a moron.

Definitely the most idiotic post in this thread.

EDIT:

I suggest you read up on the distinction between "sexual predator" and "child molestor".

 

he would be classified as a sexual predator - still illegal, but this thread was made solely to discuss chemical castration as a punishment/cure for child molesters...people who engage in the rape of children (from newborns up to the age of 12.)

sexual predator...in between a pedo and a homo.

 

It takes some sick freak to rape an 18 month old baby. Those people should never, ever be set free. Fit for society? Not likely.

Is your friends niece okay?

 

Minor attracted Gay Sexuial Predator ?

 

Are you a member by chance? Not an attack on you just curious thats all.

 

The drs told the mother despite her young age she will have psychological problems and one being she will either be frigid or promiscuous..... she turned out to be the latter...

And of course, she went thru a couple surgeries to mend the horrific tearing....

When Shirley told me about her niece, I couldn't even speak. You hear about this stuff, then when a friend tells you about her baby niece, you do feel her pain and the pain of all the other little ones who were so brutally attacked........ about the only way I can explain it..........

And that's the reason why I believe in the DP - monsters like him & John Couey who raped and buried alive 8 yr old Jessica don't deserve to live. They're not normal, never will be normal and why should the taxpayers pay for their miserable existence for the rest of their abnormal lives? I refuse to call them 'animals' b/c even animals treat the babies better than some so-called 'humans' do........

And this is another reason why I don't believe every 'diagnosis' every psychiatrist/psychologist or medical doctor says..... that evil POS killed the baby's psyche and ruined her life - an innocent baby - yet he only got 6 months in prison and a 'qualified' psychiatrist said 6 months later he should be freed and the parole board let him go.........

 

I don't know what to say to this. Its just too sickening for words.
I cannot believe some psychologist said this guy should be released after just six months, and they let him go! I wouldn't be surprised if he raped someone else after he was released.

I remember years ago, driving in the car, and hearing about a 9 month old baby being raped. I don't know where it was but I think it was in Australia. The very thought of someone actually doing that, and what possesses them, is just...enough to make you want to throw up.

Ugh. I am so sorry for your friends niece. She deserves a whole lot better.

 

I voted no because the punishment I want for them would make castration redundant. Honestly, with few exceptions, they should serve life in prison. My childhood friend's dad turned out to be a pedo and he is currently finishing up a 7 year sentence and I know for a fact that he did not learn his lesson. I don't think I've ever heard of a case where a child molester, after serving time, becomes reformed. That's not to say that they don't learn to not act on their urges, but they usually always still have the urges.

 

Uh, no but anyone left of Center here in America is trending towards support of LGBT & their NAMBLA allies .

 

As much as I wish harm on pedophiles, I don't think the government should be in the buiessnes of mutilating bodies.

 

It doesn't mean jack sh*t to me, when an innocent child has been violated.

 

Repeat offenders shouldn't be let out of prison for any reason, there should be no argument- i don't care if the Pope himself said he/she should be.

first time offenders should be allowed out either, but i would be willing to hear arguments on it.

Castration no, that would be crule and unusual punishment, but life in jail or the death penalty yes.

 

Planet Reality.

previously you spoke about adults and children. In my home state, you are a legal adult at age 17. before that you are a child. when a law like the ludicrous idea of castration in this thread, takes effect the law will make no difference between a 17 and 16 year old more than a 40 year old and a 7 year old. two adults and two children. there is no teenager in the literature. this is simply a practical example that shows your idea is equally ludicrous.

 

Its funny when presented with this real life example of the flaw in the reasoning of the castraters, that somehow your question is off topic.

their inability to answer this question just lost them the debate.

good form Makkede.

 

That's not a child molester though. Child molestation, or pedophilia, is sex with a person under the age of 13 I believe (at least in the US). What you are describing is statutory rape (there is another ----philia word for it but I can't think of it), or sex with a minor above 13.