POLL: Should the Palestinians go back to Jordan?

The Palestinians, currently occupying huge swathes of the Jewish State of Israel, are committing terrorism pretty much every day.

So far, we have showed restraint against these terrorists. But soon, the time will come when we say "Never again".

We have been persecuted by the Nazis and will not allow the Palestinians to terrorize us.

Please vote on this critical poll.

 

Ever the victims, zionists steal the Palestinians land but still bleat about them fighting for the land they lived on. The Holocaust Industry used to allow Zionists to oppress others. The majority of Jews before 1939 wanted nothing to do with zionism.

 

Just in case anyone believes the Zionist lies regarding where Palestinians come from here is the UN report from 1947 showing how the indigenous population grew.

These changes in the population have been brought about by two forces: natural increase and immigration. The great increase in the Jewish population is due in the main to immigration. From 1920 to 1946, the total number of recorded Jewish immigrants into Palestine was about 376,000, or an average of over 8,000 per year. The flow has not been regular, however, being fairly high in 1924 to 1926, falling in the next few years (there was a net emigration in 1927) and rising to even higher levels between 1933 and 1936 as a result of the Nazi persecution in Europe. Between the census year of 1931 and the year 1936, the proportion of Jews to the total population rose from 18 per cent to nearly 30 per cent.

16. The Arab population has increased almost entirely as a result of an excess of births over deaths. Indeed, the natural rate of increase of Moslem Arabs in Palestine is the highest in recorded statistics,1 a phenomenon explained by very high fertility rates coupled with a marked decline in death rates as a result of improved conditions of life and public health, The natural rate of increase of Jews is also relatively high, but is conditioned by a favorable age distribution of the population due to the high rate of immigration.
https://unispal.un.org/DPA/DPR/unispal.nsf/0/07175DE9FA2DE563852568D3006E10F3

 

The Palestinians aren't from Jordan.

 

The Palestinians should go back home to Jordan. They will be warmly greeted by their Palestinian Queen of Jordan.

For those who don't go, we will allow them to create a demilitarised "Palestine" in the Gaza strip. But if terror comes from the strip, the IDF will act.

 

Other: They should be left alone.

 

The Palestinians aren't from Jordan.

 

You're advocating ethnic cleansing - a well recognized humanitarian crime.

I'd point out that THIS YEAR has the highest rate of Israelis bulldozing the homes of Palestinians in West Bank.

And, their primary excuse???

Israel doesn't recognize their building permits!!

If an occupying nation was bulldozing the homes of families in YOUR city, what would YOU do?

Well, in West Bank what is actually happening is that the government of Palestine is seen by the IDF occupation forces as their most important partner in SECURITY. Their government has consistently used its forces and influence to demand that NONVIOLENT means for resolution be used.

Then we get some tweaker from the US come along and suggest committing a heinous criminal act on those who have lived there for centuries!!!

 

well, he is a right-wing Zionist.

 

We will only leave them alone once they stop terrorizing us. As long as the terrorism continues, we will continue liberating them of their evil.

- - - Updated - - -

And you're a declared left wing Zionist, so I welcome you as a defender of Israel

 

I can't vote, because neither option seems appealing.

Why back to Jordan?

I'm against transfer. Should an official Palestinian state be founded in Jordan, I wouldn't send Arabs from Yehuda, Shomron and Gaza there. It should be their choice, and theirs alone.

We should sue the Palestinian leadership in every possible court of law, be it national or international, for incitement to murder, complicity, and accessory to crime. We should sue every NGO that supports - financially or otherwise - the Palestinian leadership. We should sue UNRWA for teaching kids in their schools to hate and kill Jews.

We should hunt the leaders down like diseased and dangerous animals, and work only with young, educated, open-minded Palestinians.

 

Some good comments here on how we should deal with the Palestinian terrorists, in addition to IDF strategies.

 

Palestinians aren't from Jordan.

this right-wing lie needs to go away.

 

Jordan has more than 60% of Palestine, that's why some people think it should be the Palestinian's state. Oddly enough ,nobody ever asked the Hashemite rulers of Jordan to make painful concession for their Palestinian brethren, or to return to their native Arabian Peninsula.

 

most of Jordan was NEVER part of historical Palestine

 

The Arab homes the Israelis are destroying in East Jerusalem are hundreds of years old.. They are being destroyed to build low cost, government subsidized housing for Haredi .

 

Who cares about Palestinians right now, when Muslim hordes are overrunning Europe?

 

The premise of your question is false. They were not born in Jordan, so they can't go back there. Palestinian Arabs have lived in the area now called Palestine for generations, even before the founding of the state of Israel. It's problematic to even deport them from the state of Israel, because Israel refuses to establish any permanent fixed borders. There is no legal, historical, or moral justification for deporting people to areas their ancestors never lived.

If Israel intends to deport Arabs from the state of Israel, then it should go ahead and do so, and stop bombarding us with utterly obvious propaganda.

 

As long as zionist criminals and leaders also get theirs, I see no problems in that.

Ridiculous excuse for a poll, BTW. Does it reflect the education youngsters get in Israel?

 

Yes, I've discussed this matter with a friend of mine, a young American Jew who has migrated to Israel [now he studies there and he served in the IDF]. Substantially I had to agree with him: Jordan is the natural land for Palestinians.

Someone could wonder: "why not Palestine?"

The answer is easy: because historical Philistines are no more and the definition "Palestine" is based on fantasy ...

 

Maybe he was more convincing with gestures... because presented like that... I'll pass.

 

What one believe tends to naturally align with one's interests. To be totally frank, there are no 'natural' lands - and the idea that there are such natural homelands is also a fantasy. Every square inch of this blasted planet is claimed by someone, many times over. Their reasoning seems perfectly obvious to them.

And yes, Palestine is fantasy, just as Israel was a fantasy until it was made real by brute force. The only way Palestine can be made real is by the use of brute force as well. Of course, to you this force is criminal thuggery. It is no different than the perception of Begin as a criminal thug when he blew up the King David Hotel, killing 91. It is no different than the perception of Arabs driven from their lands they had lived on for generations.

This is the nature of the state. In order to be created, and in order to be sustained, it must exercise force. We all understand this. Israel's right to exist is a fantasy made real by its ability to enforce that right - the same is true of the US or any other state. You are justified in quashing Palestinian state ambitions if it is your state interest. Just please refrain from bamboozling us with phoney moralistic arguments.

 

Very dishonest.. Look at the Turkish census of 1870.

The Phillistines were sea people probably from the Greek islands.

 

Here's a map of Jordan:



Here are maps of Palestine in the 19th century:
http://www.miklianmaps.com/shop/johnson-map-of-palestine-1863-2/

Go argue with historians and cartographers.

You've never visited Jerusalem, have you?

One Israeli posts a comment on a forum, everybody and their in-laws automatically assume that he represents the whole community, the state, the government, the Jewish Galactic Congress.

The sad part is, I stopped wondering why long time ago.

 

Exactly. It is pure ethnic cleansing. They are stealing these people's property, bulldozing their homes and driving them away.

What I don't understand is how there is so LITTLE violence in West Bank.