Waterboarding Khalid Sheikh Mohammed DID NOT LEAD TO THE CAPTURE OF OSAMA BIN LADEN!!

No. Killing their worthless Islamonazi murderous asses is quite sufficient.

 

I would give up info to keep MY kids from being raped....wouldnt you?

 

That is not nor has it been the case. You are injecting a rediculous strawman to redirect the conversation away from the fact that Hisloserness benefitted from a technique he abhors. If he had real principles he would not have used information gained by methods he disaproved of. But of coarse, we all know that Chairman O'Bama has nothing the even closely resembles a principle.

 

noobdy said it was the case, im asking why not...

why not threaten to rape their kids?

or smash their toes with a hammer?

why NOT?

 

What 2006 & 7 water boarding?
http://www.armytimes.com/news/2007/11/ap_armywaterboarding_071113/

OBAMA Got Osama 2011
6 years after water boarding was stopped and 2 and a half years after the Bush admin.

 

According to the document that you just cited they could potentially and 'legitimately' execute said CIA agent. Waterboarding kinda' pales in comparison, no?

 

Except we didn't sign all those provisions.

 

so I guess we come full circle

can any foreign power that didnt sign those provisions torture our CIA agents freely?

 

pre or post trial?

 

No and since we didn't. It depends on the laws of those countries I guess.

 

would anyone mind if the navy seals took turns raping bin ladens wife in front of him until he gave them information?

 

interesting....so domestic laws come into play when you are torturing people who arent covered by the GC?

 

What does that have to do with the EIT we use?

 

Well DUH..............what other law would?

 

and is torture legal or illegal here?

 

nothing....im suggesting some new options that I can almost guarantee would get someone talking

or is there some line im not aware of?

 

What you’re saying is that the person would have "fessed up" without the discomfort that the water boarding would have brought? What a fat load of bull that is. You can just ask these guys something and get them to answer a question without some kind of retribution for no answer…

 

Of course not. But the EIT methods we use are.

 

As I thought.

 

then why limit them to 3 guys over only 1 year?

 

I was honest, I thought where we draw the line and why would be an interesting tanget. but I dont honestly expect conservatives to be interested in that much introspection

 

Post........

 

sounds like an improvement from waterboarding already

 

Would you rather be waterboarded or executed?

Note that I don't condone torture or extra-judicial punishment but your question about CIA agents being waterboarded failed to hit the mark since the 'legal' available punishments far exceed waterboarding.

 

would I rather be waterboarded or have a chance to prove my innocence but risk death?

how does it go....give me liberty or pretend to drown me?